Pizza restaurants

Picadilly Pizza & Subs

3.8 39 reviews 05:00 AM - 10:00 PM 5607 Sunset Hwy, Cashmere, WA 98815, United States

Discover this place

Picadilly Pizza & Subs is a casual eatery located on Sunset Highway in Cashmere, Washington. It specializes in classic American-style pizza and freshly made submarine sandwiches. The menu features a wide selection of subs including club combo, ham, turkey, roast beef, Italian, vegetarian, and cold cut options. Pizza offerings range from simple one-topping pies to more elaborate varieties such as garden, combo, taco, and meat lovers, alongside specialty creations like Philly cheesesteak and breakfast pizzas.

The atmosphere at Picadilly Pizza & Subs is straightforward and relaxed, catering to locals seeking a convenient spot for dine-in or takeout. The focus is on delivering familiar, hearty meals made from fresh ingredients. Its range of customizable choices makes it a notable option for those wanting traditional comfort food with a variety of topping combinations. Situated in a small-town setting, the restaurant serves as a reliable neighborhood destination for quick, satisfying meals centered around pizza and subs.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Picadilly Pizza & Subs before visiting.

Reviews for Picadilly Pizza & Subs

3.8

39 reviews

100%

43%

22%

16%

27%

Review highlights

Based on 39 reviews

Picadilly Pizza & Subs in Cashmere, WA consistently receives positive feedback for its delicious, fresh pizzas and flavorful sub sandwiches. Customers frequently highlight the generous toppings, reasonable pricing, and the reliability of orders being hot and ready on time. The restaurant’s clean and organized environment is often noted, alongside friendly and attentive staff, contributing to an inviting atmosphere. While service is generally praised, occasional minor inconsistencies are mentioned but do not detract significantly from the overall experience. Overall, Picadilly Pizza & Subs is regarded as a dependable local favorite, especially appreciated for its quality food and welcoming service during busy times.

Kristi Alemazkour

Mar 04, 2026

The customized Pizzas were delicious, hot and fresh. Definitely found our regular pizza spot. Clean organized store.

Nicole Gray

Mar 03, 2026

Love love love the pizza... and all the employees are awesome except maybe 1 other than that its a great place

shane jones

Feb 03, 2026

great sub sandwiches made here, way better than. subway. better priced too.

ReBecca Cazzanigi

Jan 23, 2026

Surprisingly good pizzas, reasonably priced, with generous toppings and always hot and ready to pick up when they tell you they will be. Everything always looks clean and the staff is really friendly. Their pizzas are a lifesaver on busy nights!

Abraham Tapatio

Jan 22, 2026

i was heading to get some food when i saw the store at the corner of my eye and decided to give it a try, very nice guy at the register, i ordered a pepperoni pizza was a 30 minute wait but that’s expected at any pizza place. When i opened the box the smell was amazing it looked great and the taste was something else by itself. the pizza tasted very good haven’t had pizza this good in ages and it’s very cheesy just how i like it

Tyler Anderson

Jan 10, 2026

I have to say I get at least one pizza or sub a week yes and why ? Because it's DELICIOUS!! MMMmmm Roast beef & Swiss and all the toppings. OMG! Thank you Picadilly.

Gretchen

Jan 01, 2026

We were attending an event at the fairgrounds where there was no food being served so we popped into this gas station/convenience store that made fresh food. I questioned how long some of the stuff in hot food warmer had been there and went straight to the made-to-order pizza and subs area. I ordered and ham and cheese sandwich and the person preparing it did a meticulous, conscientious job! Instead of slapping the ham and toppings on, he very carefully lay everything out evenly. Only criticism was the thick bread.

Chris Bach

Dec 27, 2025

Great little place literally around the corner from me. Their hot food is really delicious, with their ranch sauce pizza and fried chicken as major stand-outs. Their subs are delicious too, with fresh and plentiful vegetables. My only complaint is their breakfast food. I love breakfast but I have to pass here.